Wage Compression And Symbolic Egalitarianism Essay

1907 words - 8 pages

An organisations internal pay structure can affect the way employees perform to the business strategy. Where a workers performance not only depends on the level of pay they receive (Solow, 1979, in Alexopoulos & Cohen, 2003), but also takes into consideration their pay compared to workers above and below them, those within the same occupational group, and the external labour market (Akerlof and Yellen, 1990). Pfeffer (2005) argues that wage compression, which is the act of reducing the size of the pay differences among employees, improves productivity. To gain competitive advantage, organisations need to acknowledge not only hierarchical wage compression (between management and employees) ...view middle of the document...

There is also a range of returns employees can receive; the psychological relational returns (learning opportunities, employment security), and total compensation returns which are transactional (benefits such as work/life balance, allowances, as well as cash compensation and bonuses) (Milkovich, Newman, Gerhart, 2011).

However, the validity of Pfeffers’ argument is contestable. Although compressing the pay structure supports fairness and equality, there is also the problem of creating the opposite outcome. When wage differentials are eliminated, it may not be perceived as fair and create a negative effect on effort and motivation (Kraft, 1994). A Swedish study demonstrates this negative effect, whereby the higher paid workers morale and effort subsided leading to lower outputs as they did not feel valued for their skills (Hibbs and Locking, 2000, in Alexopoulos & Cohen, 2003). Therefore, wage differentials aid in distinguishing between workers abilities and responsibilities to organisational performance (Beaumont & Harris, 2003). Theorists have thus developed a counter argument, that it is in fact wage dispersion that leads to increased effort and performance (Lallemand, Plasman, & Rycx, 2004). Instead of emphasising co-operation, Lazear and Rosen’s (1981) ‘tournament’ theory highlights the need to differentiate pay, as larger variations are more motivating than smaller or equal differences. However, unlike egalitarian pay structures that stress cohesiveness, this hierarchical model supports performance based systems that revolve around individual effort and competition (Milkovich, Newman, Gerhart, 2011). It is argued that those with lower wages will work harder to aspire to that level (Milkovich, Newman, Gerhart, 2011). Yet, the downside is that sabotage may ensue due to secrecy (Lazear, 1989).

Symbolic egalitarianism is another principle that Pfeffer (2005) advocates. The term recognises equality by minimising differences in status symbols (Bowie, 1998). By decentralising the separation between individuals in an organisation, it will develop competitive success through increasing cooperation and commitment among different groups to reach shared goals as well as creating a continual learning atmosphere (Pfeffer, 2005). Enhanced communication and interactivity across levels means that management knows what is happening and is able to make better-quality decisions directly (Pfeffer, 2005). Therefore, symbolic egalitarianism endorses fairness and respect as it collapses the ‘us’ versus ‘them’ dynamic as well as weakening discrimination. This is beneficial as every employee is judged as a valuable player and contributor to the organisation (Bowie, 1998). Therefore, symbolic egalitarianism encourages not only growth of the company but also reinforces individual progression as employees are not bound by enforced dress codes, reserved parking, or the office design (Pfeffer, 2005).

While creating social equality is an advantage to some,...

Other Essays Like Wage Compression And Symbolic Egalitarianism

Programming Solution Essay

574 words - 3 pages services and the finance department. The development team will perform these upgrades efforts in 4 separate environmental leading up to production implementation. The process to use to eliminate the time and wage problem is to replace the current system with an updated system to log the correct pay amount and days worked. The old system will be replaced with WAN Optimization technology. This new application will enable the acceleration for

Gender and Development Theories, Wid, Wad and Gad, Their Strengths and Weaknesse

1123 words - 5 pages Correcting the modernization theory of development is necessary Modernization theory of development see underdevelopment and poverty are stages in development process resulting from lack of social,economic and political condtiotns for development to take place Women’s subordination within modernist paradigm was judged as backwardness and primitiveness of development programme They argue that modernization lead to egalitarianism and female

Identification of the Mexican Monetary Policy and the Fiscal and Monetary Indicators

1298 words - 6 pages policy-makers had projected at the outset of the reforms. The lacklustre response of the Mexican economy represents more than a longer-than-expected adjustment lag. Rather, through an analysis of state policy in the urban–industrial and rural–agricultural sectors of the economy, it can be said that the sources of slow growth and wage compression are the particular mix of policies that have been implemented under the banner of neoliberalism in Mexico

Main Challenges Facing The Contemporary World Economy

1987 words - 8 pages The world economy is a dynamic, multifarious and complex entity. The contemporary economy can be distinguished from past economies simply because technology permits a greater degree of interdependence than has previously been possible. An integral facet of the 21st century economy is what Harvey (1989) identifies as ‘Time-Space Compression’, the phenomenon described by Larsson (2003, pg.89) as “The process of world shrinkage”. This “shrinkage

Social Justice

1369 words - 6 pages initiated the concept of a living wage. Father Coughlin also used the term in his publications in the 1930s and the 1940s. It is a part of Catholic social teaching, Social Gospel from Episcopalians and is one of the Four Pillars of the Green Party upheld by green parties worldwide. Social justice as a secular concept, distinct from religious teachings, emerged mainly in the late twentieth century, influenced primarily by philosopher John Rawls. Some

English Literature

1980 words - 8 pages 1. Allegory: A tale in verse or prose in which characters, actions, or settings represent abstract ideas or moral qualities. An allegory is a story with two meanings, a literal meaning and a symbolic meaning. 2. Alliteration: The repetition of the initial consonant sounds in poetry. 3. Allusion: A reference to a person, a place, an event, or a literary work that a writer expects the reader to recognize and respond to. An allusion may be drawn

Hrm 430 Midterm

1434 words - 6 pages ) The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 addresses which three issues? | |   | Student Answer: | | minimum wage, overtime pay, & child-labor |   | | | minimum wage, overtime pay, pay discrimination |   | | | minimum wage, child-labor, pay discrimination |   | | | overtime pay, child-labor, pay discrimination |   | Instructor Explanation: | Textbook pg. 51 | | |   | Points Received: | 5 of 5 |   | Comments

To What Extent Have Gender Inequalities Been Reinforced, Rather Than Reduced by Social Policy in Germany and Sweden

4666 words - 19 pages among wage-earners by legislating distinct programs for different class and status groups, each with its own conspicuously unique set of rights and privileges which was designed to accentuate the individual's appropriate station in life. The second objective was to tie loyalties of the individual directly to the monarchy or the central state authority.” (EspingAndersen, 1990:24) In his study, 'The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism' Esping

Usa Market in Terms of “Consumer Trends” and the Effects of “Competitive Rivalry in the Retail Sectors”

3757 words - 16 pages more are projected to be completed. The consumption trend has touched all social classes, including low-income Venezuelans. A growing state work force, new government benefits, and a rising minimum wage have helped put money in Venezuelans' pockets, even as high inflation has eaten away at those gains. 4. Reflecting upon the totality of our seminar content, what are the key considerations and mindsets a non-U.S. businessperson/business must

Conflict Theory in Education System

679 words - 3 pages The education system is an ever changing system and because of this there can be three social sciences called upon to describe what the education system is for and how it operates. The three sciences are functionalism which states that every aspect of society functions in a way that everyone has a common goal and works together to reach said goal, symbolic interaction which states that people develop their own goals and views through symbolic

Change Management-Resistance To Change

2125 words - 9 pages change to manage, they will quickly lose their enthusiasm for participation in change; If they think the change may have a negative impact both on the company and themselves, the progress of change would become much more frustrated. • Unfair sense is also considered as a barrier to change. An important feature of change is to abandon the original egalitarianism and recognise the gap between revenue. According to U.S. psychologist Stasi

Related Papers

Mexican And Cuban Revolution Essay

1298 words - 6 pages . Egalitarianism was way more pronounced in Cuba because assets were snatched away from foreign owners along with foreign enterprises and upper class families and either redistributed or used to provide health, education ,sewage system and other social services. State wages were granted and wage differences were reduced in Cuba , in Mexico too you had laborers which were organized and labor unions were formed, even though workers had better wages ,these labor

Hrm Business Law Essay

2830 words - 12 pages -saving strategies, and reduced overtime” (Gootnick, 2014). Let’s not forget those whom have been working and moved up in a company and are making at or slightly above the proposed minimum wage. It is predicted that “a higher minimum wage leads to a "ripple effect" in the internal wage structure as firms raise the pay of above-minimum wage employees to maintain morale while still allowing for some internal wage compression among employees with higher

Making It In America Essay

723 words - 3 pages conditions that were favorable for people with less skills. The development of mass production allowed low- skilled farmers to move to the city, get a job in a factory and typically make more money than they ever had on a farm. What economist deemed the “Great Compression” – (the time when the income of the unskilled came closest to the income of the skilled), raised the standard of living for unskilled laborers. A few things have changed since

Mesoamerica And Complex Societies Essay

823 words - 4 pages to the Late Classic Maya Period. During this transformation period, Mesoamerica adopted new technology, implemented social identities and political reforms, established symbolic and religious meanings and improved intercity relations which all coincided with the systems theory used in processual archaeology. State complex was achieved at the beginning of Maya civilisation with the agricultural surplus allowing craft specialisation to occur. The