“(We Can) Conceive Of Twentieth Century Management Theory As Being Involved In A Double Movement Of Constructing Organizational Reality And Rationality While Effacing The Process Of Construction Behind A Mask Of Science

2110 words - 9 pages

CRITICAL PERSPECTIVES – (BY ROBERT PHILIP ACQUAH)

“(We can) conceive of twentieth-century management theory as being involved in a double movement of constructing organizational reality and rationality while effacing the process of construction behind a mask of science and naturalness, we can see Critical Management Studies as being engaged in a project of undoing this work, of deconstructing the reality of organizational life or truthfulness of organizational knowledge by exposing its un-naturalness or irrationality.”
Delbridge and Keenoy, 2010.

Introduction
Following on from the latter part of the 19th century, the turn of the 20th century ushered in a management paradigm ...view middle of the document...

Heralded by the contingency movement, critical management studies (CMS) emerged. Based on a premise of promoting human enlightenment and emancipation, critical theorists argue that knowledge is multidimensional (Ogbor, 2001), debunking established assumptions and practices of the classical (conventional) movement. These arguably find expressions in the modernist and post-modernist discourse.

Classical management theory
Rationality and the “rational organization”, arguably the most influential management thought in the twentieth century gained momentum from Frederick Taylor and Max Weber’s theories of scientific and bureaucratic management respectively (Rutgers, 1999). The concept of rationality became the cornerstone of management praxis that is structured, mechanistic, functional and hierarchical concerned with production efficiency by managing available resources in a static and stable environment (Khalil, 2000).

Whilst there is a general consensus that organizational theory fuelled by the classical movement has evolved through rationality to establish a coherent system of management practices and thought, the main criticism that characterize the classical thought (namely scientific management, administrative principles and bureaucratic organization) is its emphasis on the economic rationality of management and organizations (Sridhar, 2009). It is argued that the classical thought ignores or takes a dim view of human aspects of the organization. Furthermore, the prescription of one best way of doing things, the belief that economic incentive is key to worker motivation and the monotony of work specialization are some of the key criticism of the classical view.

In spite of these criticisms, the classical paradigm is credited with making major contributions to the development of management functions, alongside the application of science to management and the articulation of specific principles to management (Sridhar, 2009).

Frederick W. Taylor’s principles of scientific management whilst replacing the “rule of thumb” philosophy, established scientific application to work processes and functional divisions which has widespread applications in modern management. Taylor’s “time and motion study” at the Bethlehem steel plant convinced him that work was more efficient when broken down into constituent parts whilst planning and decision making functions became the remit of management. Jean-Louis Peucelle (2000) contends that there are a number of Taylor’s prescriptions such as the formalization of prescribed work still present in modern enterprises today and likely to remain so for the foreseeable future.

Max Weber’s contribution to organizational theory stems from his ideological prescriptions of a bureaucratic type of organizational structure with hierarchical authority and responsibilities that prescribes a controlled structure imbued with specialized functions, rules and regulations also in the name of efficiency.

The...

Other Essays Like “(We Can) Conceive of Twentieth-Century Management Theory as Being Involved in a Double Movement of Constructing Organizational Reality and Rationality While Effacing the Process of Construction Behind a Mask of Science

Last Year, Mr. Smith Was Involved in an Automobile Accident, Severely Injuring His Legs. as a Part of a Long-Term Rehabilitation Process, His Physician Prescribes a Daily Routine of Swimming. Because...

1778 words - 8 pages Case: Last year, Mr. Smith was involved in an automobile accident, severely injuring his legs. As a part of a long-term rehabilitation process, his physician prescribes a daily routine of swimming. Because there is not readily available public facility nearby, Mr. Smith purchases a house with a pool for $175,000. Replacing the pool would cost $20,000. The existing pool increases the fair market value of the house by $8,000. Mr. Smith

How the Beats Influenced Social Movements in the Later Half of the Twentieth Century

1698 words - 7 pages Essay Question: How did the beat generation influence other sociauikhuhuhjl movements that occurred in the second half of the twentieth century? By Brydie Siryj The origins of the beat movement can be traced back to Columbia University where Jack Kerouac, Allen Ginsberg, Lucien Carr, Hal Chase and others met. It was at Columbia University where the future beats discussed and shared ideas that would later lead to the experimentation of drugs

English Language As A Medium Of Instruction For Science And Mathematics In Malaysia

1734 words - 7 pages of Science concepts in English (Faizah Mohamad Nor, Marzilah A. Aziz & Jusoff, K., 2011). According to the study carried out by Aziz bin Nordin (n.d.), he stated that respondents were having problems more obvious in learning Science since Science subject comprises a lot of factors, concepts and principles as well as problem solving process in its content. Cheah and Nor Azmi Mostafa (2009) discovered that language was the barrier for students to

A Closer Examination Of Paolo Sarpi And The Uses Of Information In The Seventeenth-Century Venice

1894 words - 8 pages thought, psychological organization, and social and institutional organization, and that the media are never neutral as shown by propaganda charged political writings (Black, Chunn, Edwards and Heyer 2). The reference article, Filippo De Vivo’s paper Paolo Sarpi and the Uses of Information in the Seventeenth-Century Venice, is structured very much like a standard essay in that it has an introduction, thesis, supporting paragraphs for the points

On the Folly of Rewarding a While Hoping for

4524 words - 19 pages © Academy of Management Executive. 1995 Vol. 9 No.1 AN ACADEMY CLASSIC On the folly of rewarding A, while hoping for B Steven Kerr Executive Overview This article, updated for AME, needs no introduction.1 Even today, the original article is still widely reprinted. Now part of the lexicon, it truly qualifies as an Academy of Management Classic for almost twenty years, its title has reminded executives and scholars alike-it's the reward

“a Critical Assesment of Religion Today in the Philippines: Reality and Challenges; Weaknesses and Oppurtunities”

822 words - 4 pages RONIE BOTONA RESEARCH AND METHODOLOGY I Professor: Fr. Dave Capucao “A CRITICAL ASSESMENT OF RELIGION TODAY IN THE PHILIPPINES: REALITY AND CHALLENGES; WEAKNESSES AND OPPURTUNITIES” Religion is humanity’s way to be in connection with the divine. It can be traced centuries ago. In the Philippines, religion existed already during pre-colonialization. However it was only during the colonialization period that religion becomes a power to

Can There Be A Grand Unified Theory Of Psychology? Discuss

1106 words - 5 pages this sort of therapy as a theory however because all the Eclectic Psychologist is doing is ignoring the fundamental ideological underpinnings of the particular theories he is using and taking the parts relevant to their client in therapy This essay will explore one of the possible combinations of theories on personality and explain how it can be applied in practical therapy. Eysenkes theory of biological bases in behaviour is the base of this

The Role, Responsibilities and Boundaries of Being a Teacher

1306 words - 6 pages Strategy which in turn is extracted from the EDEXCEL Standards. Once the evaluation process as been carried out the resulting outcomes can be fed back into the system ready for planning and preparation of the next lesson, intake or term. In conclusion it as been demonstrated that the teaching cycle is a neatly interlocking self-fluctuating loop, each stage dependent on the previous and affecting the next, in certain circles

Three Defining Moments In Canadian History In The 20th Century, And Prove Their Significance To The Maturation Of Canada As A Nation (I Created This Question)

1627 words - 7 pages to the amount every civilian can buy. As in WWI, total war meant that all industries, materials, and people were put to work for the war effort. The war basically affected everyone in Canada. In a very real sense, however, Canada also grew with the war. WWII helped Canada establish its place as an important "middle power" among world nations, while its GNP (Gross National Production) of goods (asbestos, aluminium, coal, manganese, chemicals, and

Constructing the Public Perception of Sports

1005 words - 5 pages Constructing the Public Perception of Sports Mass media has become a dominant factor on sports culture in today’s society. “Mass media serve as a dominant hegemonic force in American culture, resulting in the construction and reinforcement of narratives, particularly in professional sports” (Berg & Harthcock). The media can be held responsible for creating the majority of the public’s perception of sports to this day. The heavy dosage of

The Importance Of Being A Visionary Individual

736 words - 3 pages main person to have fought for the independence of our country. Tunku Abdul Rahman visualized Malaysia as being independent through strong leadership. If it was not for our ‘ Father of Independence’, we would still be under the colonization of the British government.To be a visionary individual, we must have a strong mind and a strong character. In this modern society, we must learn not to be affected by others. Even though the environment

Related Papers

What Is The Role Of The Creativity In The Segmentation Process, Why Can We Say That Having An Excellent Global Positioning Is One Of The Principal Assets Of A Brand, What Criteria Should Global...

5017 words - 21 pages Joseph Lanton Adjei Mensah This paper is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for International Marketing SMC University School of Management Professor (Dr.) Babu P George January 6, 2014 (Submission Date) Unit – 2 What is the role of the creativity in the segmentation process, Why can we say that having an excellent global positioning is one of the principal assets of a brand, What criteria should global

Can We Leave The Past Behind?

2778 words - 12 pages importance of the mother/child relationship and the way the child was parented would affect the adult in later life. Object Relations Theory holds the belief that we are relationship seeking individuals rather than pleasure seeking as Freud suggested, and this can be useful for exploring the clients past and any issues they have with intimacy or dependency and identity. The “object” being a person or an actual object that is significant to the individual

How Can We Distinguish Between Science And Pseudo Science?

675 words - 3 pages processes on how stars are formed by the fusion of hydrogen and helium to create a sphere of plasma, and how these stars can shine together to form patterns that we see in the night sky as constellations. However, it seems scientifically implausible on the other hand in explaining how constellations can give people certain characteristics when they are born under a certain star sign. Astrology as a pseudo-science, compared to astronomy, which is

Construction Of The Hero In A Piece Of Writing

1826 words - 8 pages Construction of the Hero in a Piece of Writing The construction of the ‘Hero’ is one every writer should consider. The hero or protagonist is designed to keep the narrative moving and whose actions create progress for the plot (Morrow et al, 1997). Pearson (2001, p. 101) defines hero’s as “fearless protagonists who realise their own special power and go on to take great personal risks in order to change their reality. In day-to-day life