Welfare Reform Package: Helping Individuals Help Themselves

1991 words - 8 pages

It is nearly impossible to support one particular stance on the political spectrum for societal issues across the board. I have always placed myself in the libertarian category on the political spectrum, in the sense that I believe the government should refrain from passing laws that impose on individual freedom and support privatization and the free market. When it comes to the welfare state, I don’t think that the key to a successful reform necessarily lies in the cutting back of government spending, but rather a redistribution of the budget. I recognize the need for government assistance but firmly believe that more emphasis needs to be put on providing opportunities for individuals ...view middle of the document...

One of the most important changes that developed from this reform package was the creation of “Temporary Assistance for Needy Families” (TANF), the current food stamp program that ultimately replaced the AFDC. Through TANF the federal government gives grants to each state and in turn the state distributes the aid to the population in need while theoretically abiding by the restrictions and requirements placed on those receiving aid. This program requires that recipients will be eligible for no more than five years, out of their entire life, for cash assistance, and that work must be found within two years as a recipient.
According to the United States Welfare Data for 2010, the federal government spent nearly 60% of its budget on mandatory payments towards human resources, cash payments and in-kind benefit programs for individuals, yet government data on the levels of poverty, for the same year, display an increase in the population living under the poverty threshold. The way that the system currently functions, as discussed in class, penalizes people for finding work while receiving benefits, as those that find work ultimately make a similar amount of money, thus live in the same conditions, as when they were solely relying on government assistance. I propose that work requirements be scaled back to a one year time frame, during which a certain amount of job training would be required. If at the end of the one year period, the recipient has not found a job, they will be placed in a government labor job or the benefits will be discontinued. This system functions very similarly to that of the JOBS program. The JOBS program seems ideal, one of the only downsides being that it requires caseworkers for individuals, which from a practical standpoint would not be very efficient as there is a rather large population involved (Morgen, Acker & Weigt, 2010). These standards could be applied to unemployment insurance, foods stamps, and a multitude of other means- tested programs. As Mead points out, “in all of these programs [means-tested social programs], a benefit or service has been offered to those eligible, but no official notice is taken of whether recipients attempt to overcome their problems,” (Bane & Mead, 2003). There is a need to be more consistent in requirements and enforcement for these training programs, between the federal and state levels, and individuals need to be pushed to utilize such resources.
The opposing viewpoint, specifically individuals that tend to fall on the left side of the political spectrum, would be likely to argue that giving welfare recipients such limited options and enforcing stricter work requirements would be discouraging to individuals and may support the status quo; a population working labor jobs and hovering around the poverty threshold. I would counter these arguments by not only pointing out the fact that by being more forceful with work requirements and job training, people would be earning their...

Other Essays Like Welfare Reform Package: Helping Individuals Help Themselves

Problem: How to get People off of Welfare

817 words - 4 pages It is a commonly known fact that a large percentage of Americans are living on and relying on welfare, which is a government program that provides financial aid to individuals or groups of people who cannot support themselves. Welfare began in the 1930’s during the Great Depression. There are several types of assistance offered by the government, which include healthcare, food stamps, child care assistance, unemployment, cash aid, and housing

Public Assistance Essay

4682 words - 19 pages food stamps. The National Coalition for the Homeless (2009) addressed the challenges people face when given a limited number of funds. As a result of loss of benefits, low wages, and unstable employment, many families who try separating themselves from welfare often struggle to receive adequate medical care, food, and housing. Not only do poor people struggle to obtain stable housing, but individuals with disabilities also experience a great

Welfare Working for or Against Single Mothers

2370 words - 10 pages two jobs to get off of welfare. She was still driving about two hours one way to get to work and never was home to help her kids with their homework; or even to attend any of the sports games. I guess the worst part of it is when I was writing this I would use words like “is” instead of “was” for past tense like I still have very strong feelings today about poverty, welfare and single mothers because I know how it affected my family and me. In the

Welfare in the Us

2600 words - 11 pages assistance and steer people quickly into jobs (The Washington Post). Prior to reform, steer were given “limitless” (The Washington Post) money by the federal government, increasing per family on welfare under the 60 year old Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) program (www.heritage.org). This gave states no incentive to direct welfare funds to the neediest recipients or to encourage individuals to go off welfare (the state lost federal money

Bush's Welfare Reform Bill

388 words - 2 pages problem. The U.S. government is dispersing over one billion between states who need help funding the new change in welfare requirements. Each individual state may have to spend from eight to eleven billion dollars to implement the new system. (Peterson) Even though the new welfare system costs a lot of money the WORK act should help many people in the long run.Overall, the WORK act of 2002 should have a positive impact upon the futures of welfare recipients by helping them overcome their financial difficulties. Furthermore, the act should deter more people from abusing the welfare system and swindling the government out of millions in order to satisfy their own needs.

An Analysis Of The Medicare Reform Package

1503 words - 7 pages Criterion: Is the Package equitable for the battlers? • The Second Criteria: Is the Package helping the rural areas of Australia? • The Third Criteria: Does the Package help the Middle class Australians? The First Criterion: Is the Package equitable for the battlers? Any political reform agenda that involves the area of health that is bought forward by the government will need to be particularly scrutinized for its equity. Medicare plays

Afforadable Health Care

2621 words - 11 pages help low and middle-income individuals and families purchase insurance.” (Kruger, 2009) Over time, the Exchange will also be opened to employers as an additional choice for covering their employees. “The new health reform law will also create separate Exchanges through which small businesses can buy coverage. It will require employers to pay penalties for employees who receive tax credits for health insurance through an Exchange, with exceptions for

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients: Scandal or Solution

1322 words - 6 pages , drug testing. Drug test everyone on welfare and when the welfare recipient tests positive, take away the benefit. Problem solved. But is it? The consideration of testing welfare recipients for drug use has been debated since welfare reform in 1996. Subsequently, “at least eight states have passed legislation regarding drug testing or screening for public assistance applicants or recipients (Arizona, Florida, Georgia, Kansas, Missouri, Oklahoma

Poverty: a Global Issue

1698 words - 7 pages . federal stimulus package that was enacted as part of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) contains about $175 billion in direct aid to individuals, including $20 billion in additional SNAP funding, $40 billion for expanded unemployment insurance benefits, and $70 billion in refundable tax credits, including the EITC. Only the expanded unemployment benefits would be counted as fighting poverty by the official U.S. statistics. The rest

Welfare - a Good Will That Should Be Restricted

1059 words - 5 pages among the hard working individuals who pay taxes and watch as their tax money is spent inefficiently (as all government spending is) and watch as apparent able-bodied people sit around their paid-for houses “living the easy life.” Anger is certainly sparked when one mentions immigrants moving to the State and immediately drawing welfare benefits all while taxes continue to rise for the working class and our state and country continue to struggle

welfare reform

1586 words - 7 pages divorced, deserted, and minority mothers and their children. Few private and government retirement pensions existed in the United States before the Great Depression. The prevailing view was that individuals should save for their old age or be supported by their children. About 30 states provided some welfare aid to poor elderly persons without any source of income. Local officials generally decided who deserved old-age assistance in their

Related Papers

Legal And Ethical Issues Concerning Welfare Reform

2128 words - 9 pages Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act.  IV. President Clinton’s changes pushed able bodied person(s) to work and support themselves and their families. Legal Issues concerning welfare reform A. Immigrants B. Requirements C. Length of time I. Immigrants that need Medicaid are not eligible. II. To receive TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) people now need to be looking for a job, working or, evolved in job

The Evaluation Of Welfare Reform: Is It Actually Ending?

1440 words - 6 pages help alleviate the current and persistent welfare dilemma. Congress has implemented welfare reform legislations that simply have not helped or changed much. The question regarding the welfare system continues to remain the same; what is wrong with welfare and can it be fixed? A question that is not simple, nor does the question have a simple answer. However, one thing is very clear; welfare is not working and needs to change, desperately. The

Welfare To Works Ride By, Yang

656 words - 3 pages welfare programs must help recipients prepare for and move into work. Further, the new law limits the time most families can receive benefits to at most five years over their lifetime. In some states the limit is 21 months.Since reform, many families have moved from welfare to work. In 1997 three-fourths of all families that left welfare had an employed adult. But many of the jobs former recipients hold are low-wage and don't come with benefits

Classic Arugment Welfare Essay

747 words - 3 pages government help. In the Welfare Reform and the General Welfare “we have built a coalition called “JOIN” that brings together neighborhood, adult literacy, child care, and human service organizations to fight for public service jobs, education and training, reverse commuting and quality child care in responding to welfare reform.”(Par. # 9) In other words the money to support these welfare programs is from the government which they have collected from