What Does It Mean To Say That Romantic Love Is A Moral Issue Do You Agree

1418 words - 6 pages

It is not easy to act both generally and individually morally, when people are blinded by passion and flourish of romantic love. That is why someone calls romantic love is a moral issue. Morality differentiate actions into right and wrong, and right actions are constituted by permissible and obligatory (Halwani 2010, p.89). We should eschew wrong actions, however, can we summarise romantic love is morally prohibited? Sometimes love hurts people when love is selfish or attachment; while sometimes love also brings happiness and support from outside of us. Romantic love is beyond dualism, just like Halwani (2010, p.92) states ' romantic love is not a basic good...it is not morally suspect ...view middle of the document...

Therefore, Ehman indicates romantic love is preferential:

The fundamental requirement of love is to raise the beloved above all others and to give her a privileged status in our life...The fundamental requirement of morality in contrast is to treat all persons as having equal worth and to justify all special treatment of a person by reference to universally valid principles. (Ehman, quoted in Halwani 2010, p.91)

Ehman pointed that morality is opposite to preferential treatment of love, does it mean that love is immoral when it involves the preferential treatment? Preferential treatment is not only applied to romantic love, but also can be found in parents-children, friendship, and other intimate relationships. In order to maintain the relationships with their families, friends and lovers, people will contribute extra time, money and attention to them. Without the notion of preferential treatment, we cannot have friends or lovers, or even our families properly. Hence, Halwani gives morality a choice: ' to accept this fact and monitor it to ensure that the treatment is not excessive or at the expense of obligations to others, or it will have to ask us to eschew intimate relationship altogether' (Halwani 2010, p.92).

Consequentialism is focus on moral result only; a particular action is morally good only if it produces a good result. In another words, consequentialism is a result based ethic. Utilitarianism is a typical example of result based ethic. This says that the morally good choice in a given situation is the one that produces the most happiness. However, Kantian ethics is centre around people’s motives. Kant claims that any action could be moral only based on the motives are moral. Motive is everything to determine the morality of an action. However, consequentialism disregards the motives involved in an action, such as utilitarians, which try to treat the action and the actor separately, and look for the most happiness and the least harm for the big picture. For example, killing an entirely innocent person, 10 other innocent persons would be saved. According to utilitarianism, killing one innocent person is justified because it would maximise utility, as 10 people saved. While Kantian ethics would say it is inherently wrong to murder people, the innocent person cannot be killed, even though it results in the death of 9 more people. Through this comparison, 'utilitarianism is too demanding...Kantian ethics is not as demanding' (Halwani 2010, p.96). Then, whether and Kantian ethics are permissible to undertake romantic love? For consequentialism, the theory requires an agent to act with an eye to treat each person equally in order to avoid the issue of favouring loved ones and partiality. Indeed, for the sake of maximising good states of affairs in a long term, 'it might allow for the idea that agent treat loved ones with the usual favouritism on the grounds' (Halwani 2003, p.93). Kant introduces a famous concept is called...

Other Essays Like What Does It Mean to Say That Romantic Love Is a Moral Issue Do You Agree

Do You Agree That Education Is No Longer the Key to Success?

989 words - 4 pages system in China and Singapore still focus very much on the transfer of knowledge through textbooks and notes. This form of education allows less room for the growth of creativity and innovation. Thus, it is unlikely for a student to climb up high on the corporate ladder in his later stages of life as he or she may only be able to regurgitate what is in the notes but not able to apply the knowledge effectively. As such, the current form of education

What Do the Terms Race and Ethnicity Mean to You

679 words - 3 pages * What do the terms race and ethnicity mean to you? * * Well I would have to say that I experienced my own struggles with racism growing up being of Caucasian and African American descent growing up in a white neighborhood. But at the same time it wasn’t just a racial issue it was a stereotypical one too. I think that people get an eschewed perspective of the world due to their upbringing the things that they are subjected to or taught


663 words - 3 pages essay on celts - gEORGIA WEBB"The celts were a barbaric and primitive people." to what extent do you agreeIn Iron Age and Medieval Europe, there were a group of tribal societies called the Celts that spread all across Europe. The Celts were believed to be semi-nomadic, moving all around Europe. Recent tells us that they were essentially located in central Europe and then migrated. More recent news, archaeological studies are now telling us that

"The Long March Was a Retreat That Changed the Destiny of China" to What Extent Do You Agree with This Statement?

1169 words - 5 pages “The Long March was a retreat that changed the destiny of China” To what extent do you agree with this statement? The Long March was an epic journey across China conducted by the Red army in 1934. After the breakdown of the first United Front, Chiang Kai Shek launched an offensive which forced a retreat from Mao and the Red army. This retreat is believed to have lasted for over a year and covered 6000 miles. By the end of the march, of the

Why Does Descartes Say That Nothing Can Ever Be Known Perfectly Without a Knowledge of God? Is It True?

1157 words - 5 pages clearly and distinctly in their mind’s eye, they are not simply convinced that God’s nature must be so. Since there is no intuitive reasoning that reveals God’s true nature, they must concede that they could be mistaken over exactly what His nature might entail and so, like the atheist, there remains a lingering doubt as to whether they are misguided. However convinced they may be of God’s essence being one thing or another, it doesn’t seem

What Do You Think Is Simon’S Importance to the Novel and How Does Golding Present Him?

866 words - 4 pages in the Bible. However, unlike Jesus, Simon does not preach ending the comparison with Jesus. Instead, he ‘became inarticulate in his effort to express man’s essential illness’. Golding here manages to highlight his main point that evil can express itself in many ways and it’s only rules and society that are suppressing it. Therefore, Simon is seen as Golding’s chief way of portraying the evil of mankind from the voice of an innocent, insightful

To What Extent Would You Agree That John Proctor Is Presented as an Honest, Strong but Ultimately Flawed Character?

1348 words - 6 pages , wanting her to react to his motion but not too much. It is even more unnerving as you know he is being “pleasant” only to get what he wants, which is to save his wife. The word “quietly” suggest a more flirtatious way of holding someone’s hand., like two school children but it could also been seen as a good part of Proctors character. “Quietly” suggest that he knows that the only way to save his wife is by getting Mary to confess that the girls

How far do you agree that Shakespeare’s portrayal of gender relations is more sinister than comic?

1668 words - 7 pages of the comedy, conforms to society by the end, perhaps because she realises that she is living in a patriarchal world and cannot change it. When Benedick asks for Beatrice, she steps forward to say ‘what is your will?’ (5/4/73).The phrase reveals tones of submissiveness which would have not been familiar to her prior to falling in love with Benedick. By removing her veil this suggests her removal of the mask of a defiant heroine and reveals a

“Referendums Are Beneficial to Democracy” to What Extent Do You Agree with This View?

904 words - 4 pages   “Referendums are beneficial to democracy” to what extent do you agree with this view? Referendum is a public vote on legislature. It is a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ on specific issues affecting a state. It is the most direct form of democracy. Referendums become a popular mechanism for making decisions under the ‘Blair’ administration. In a referendum, the government asks members of the public to help decide on an important issue. Everyone of voting

Technology Is the Best Way to Reduce the Impact of an Earthquake - to What Extent Do You Agree with This View

1136 words - 5 pages ‘Technology is the best way to reduce the impact of an earthquake’ to what extent do you agree with this view? (40 marks) An earthquake is a sudden violent shaking of the ground, typically causing great destruction, as a result of movements within the earth’s crust or volcanic action. Impacts of an earthquake can include short-term impacts such as fatalities, or long-term impacts such as income lost through lack of tourism. Technology can be

‘of Mice and Men’ Serves as a Reminder That Dreaming Is Futile. How Far Do You Agree with This Representation of the Text and Its Key Themes?

1562 words - 7 pages ‘Of Mice and Men’ serves as a reminder that dreaming is futile. How far do you agree with this representation of the text and its key themes? To first answer the question we need to define a key element, what are dreams? When we dream we contemplate the possibility of doing something or indulging in fantasies about something greatly desired. Yet they are necessary to keep the levels of hope high in people to stand for what they believe in

Related Papers

To What Extent Do You Agree That A Free Market Economy Is The Only Approach To Bringing About Economic Growth

2716 words - 11 pages To what extent do you agree with the view that only a free market approach to running the economy can bring about sustainable high levels of economic growth and development? The basic economic problem is that we, as consumers, have unlimited wants and scarce resources. (Anderton, 2008, p.1) Due to this, the questions of what shall be produced, how it will be produced, and who gets the product, arise. (Sandford, 1977, p.42) Therefore

The Underlying Theme Of Othello Is Reputation And It Is This That Culminates In The Play’s Tragedy. To What Extent Do You Agree With This Claim?

1172 words - 5 pages English Literature The Main theme of Othello is not the theme of jealousy but the theme of reputation and this is one of the main constitutes, responsible for the tragedy of the play: to what extent do you agree with this in regards to Act Two Scene Three and Act Three Scene Three? In William Shakespeare's Othello it could be thought that the main theme is Jealousy however in Act two scene three reputation become a prominent theme

To What Extent Do You Agree That A Revolution Happened In Germany At The End Of World War I

671 words - 3 pages To what extent do you agree that a revolution happened in Germany at the end of World War I In Germany between 1918 and 1919 there were major political changes. They went from being an autocracy to a democracy. A revolution is defined as a forcible overthrow of a government or social order for a new system. It was called a revolution for numerous reasons. On October 29th 1919, a mutiny started to spread near Kiel because sailors refused

What Does Judaism Mean To Me And You?

371 words - 2 pages feel a part of the Jewish people and not believe in God. Even the question of who should be considered a Jew is hotly debated.What, then, binds all people who claim to be Jewish into one people? Just what is Judaism and what does it mean to be Jewish?What follows is a short introduction to the meanings of Judaism, its beliefs, its customs, its practices, and the people who share them--the Jewish people. But keep in mind: behind every sentence much more remains unsaid. Just think of this concise introduction as a foreword to further study.