What Role Does The Method Of Governance In The Republic Assume In An Analysis Of The Viability Of Plato’s Political Constructs? How Does This Relate To A Discussion Of The Republic As A Utopian Political Ideal?

4475 words - 18 pages

ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY MAJOR ESSAY
SEMESTER I 2006
MICHAEL RADZEVICIUS 1092537

What role does the method of governance in The Republic assume in an analysis of the viability of Plato’s political constructs? How does this relate to a discussion of The Republic as a utopian political ideal?

Plato’s The Republic is one of the most influential philosophical, political and literary texts in the history of Western thought. The Republic’s system of governance is of considerable moment to an appreciation of the relationship between Plato’s political philosophy and practical political activity. In the system of governance Plato envisages as the most effective and beneficial for a particular ...view middle of the document...

The Republic’s system of governance is subsequently based upon Plato’s tripartite division of society into the following groups: the smallest group of all, the ruling ‘philosopher-kings’; their general assistants and military corps the ‘Auxiliaries’ or ‘Guardians’; and finally, the general populace. In the society of The Republic ‘the desires of the less respectable majority are controlled by the desires and the wisdom of the superior minority’.[3] For Plato, minority rule is an ineluctable necessity as ‘there are some who are naturally fitted for philosophy and political leadership, while the rest should follow their lead but let philosophy alone’.[4] Critics such as George Hourani believe that Plato ‘pays little attention to the capabilities of the third class in his ideal city, regarding them as raw material on which the Guardians exercise their art’.[5] The majority must therefore be governed by the philosopher-kings because it is the philosopher-kings alone who are biologically fit to rule.

The Republic’s system of governance can never be altered because each individual within Plato’s tripartite society is forbidden from leaving the social class to which they are biologically assigned. According to Plato, ‘quantity and quality are therefore more easily produced when a man specialises appropriately on a single job for which he is naturally fitted, and neglects all others’.[6] Subsequently, ‘interference by the three classes with each other’s jobs, and interchange of jobs between them, therefore, does the greatest harm to our state, and we are entirely justified in calling it the worst of evils’.[7] Plato does make a concession, however minor, regarding this ban on the interchange of class positions in The Republic when he expounds the ‘magnificent myth’[8] that details the mythical creation of the state’s citizens. As ‘occasionally a silver child will be born of golden parents, or a golden child of silver parents, and so on’,[9] some progression and regression amongst the classes is theoretically possible, but, ultimately, not entirely probable.[10]

Plato believes that as a ‘state whose prospective rulers come to their duties with least enthusiasm is bound to have the best and most tranquil government’,[11] the philosopher-kings, being reluctant to seize power,[12] will exist to benefit the state and the majority of its citizens. This is because the happiness of the rulers themselves is assured by doing so. Terence Irwin suggests that ‘if he [the philosopher] is a virtuous man, he should regard public service in other people’s interests as a part of the life that realises his own happiness; though the state is not designed for his happiness, he should find that his role in the state realises his happiness’.[13] Thus, ‘ruling provides the philosopher with the opportunity of overcoming his awareness of the disparity between the physical and ideal realms, for the philosopher-ruler models the social order according to the harmony of the...

Other Essays Like What Role Does the Method of Governance in the Republic Assume in an Analysis of the Viability of Plato’s Political Constructs? How Does This Relate to a Discussion of the Republic as a Utopian Political Ideal?

GCSE Coursework:Frankenstein:How Does Mary Shelley Manipulate Your Responce To The Characters Of Frankenstein And His Monster As The Story Develops?:For This I Got A Grade A/A*

1768 words - 8 pages FrankensteinHow does Mary Shelley manipulate you response to the characters of Frankenstein and his monster as the story develops?The opening paragraph sets the scene for the story. It does this from the start when it begins with. 'a dreary night in November.' This creates a sense of winter with connotations of coldness, darkness and a time of death. It's also a classic setting for a horror novel. The word 'dreary' I think is an effective

What Does A Person Get From A Religous Perspective? Relate This Back To Topics That Affect Us In Todays Society

1102 words - 5 pages Catholic views on these issues a held in high regard in society and they are therefore looked down upon. Nevertheless, as stated in the article, one does not simply turn their back on religion, as it is an important aspect of ones life. This shows that even if the 'catholic law' disapproves of persons actions, they can still always turn to the church for meaning and purpose in life.Society, however, hold a very different stance on such issues

Simonodes (Via Polemarchus) Argues In The First Book Of "The Republic" That Justice Is Paying Back What Is Due. Defend Or Argue Against This Position

1528 words - 7 pages words, Polemarchus' idea of justice, involves the notion of reciprocity or 'payback', which could be rather harmful to society as a whole. This idea does in fact seems to be self-fulfilling, but rather it its unjust, in the context of injuring someone in return for an injury. By acting in this certain manner, one can be satisfied at the fact that his or her enemy suffered just as they had. However, if all of society were to adapt to this way of

The Role Of Citizen Political Participation In Hong Kong And Singapore

851 words - 4 pages The Role of Citizen Political Participation in Hong Kong and Singapore Both Hong Kong and Singapore are city states that traditionally have lacked broad political participation, instead political decisions were left up to a small group of leaders. Historical factors were critical in determining the role of political participation in both city states. Hong Kong's history of colonial rule and the strength of the People's Action Party (PAP) in

The Political Dreams and Realities of Franklin Delano Roosevelt. Brief political life of this Democratic Roosevelt

547 words - 3 pages Democrats knew they weren't going to win, and they referred to Roosevelt's campaign as a sacrificial gesture. Many of his policies were put into place in the League of Nations.In the summer of 1921, he resumed a law career and was struck with some tragic news. At his summer home in New Brunswick, he was diagnosed poliomyelitis. His mother and many other people thought it was the end of his public career. With the help of a wheelchair, braces

How Does Miller Use Representations of Speech and Other Dramatic Techniques to Create Conflict in This Extract and in One Other Episode Elsewhere in the Play?

1076 words - 5 pages How does Miller use representations of speech and other dramatic techniques to create conflict in this extract and in one other episode elsewhere in the play? (30 marks) In this extract George is trying to convince Ann and Chris that Keller is guilty and that Steve (George and Ann’s father) is an innocent man who was framed for the killing of 21 pilots. George is hysterical as both Ann and Chris rubbish his claims and it is evident that he is

How Does Lennie and George's Dream Relate to the American Dream

1092 words - 5 pages How does Lennie and George’s dream relate to the American Dream? Traditionally, the American Dream is a national ethos of the United States of America. It is a difficult concept to describe because this dream is different for each person. But basically, it is an idea which suggests that all people can be successful, famous and wealthy through hard work, and that all people have the potential to live a happy life. The American dream may also

The Main Threat to the Weimar Republic in the Period 1919-23 Was the Extreme Right" How Far Do You Agree with This Judgement?

1005 words - 5 pages The main threat to the Weimar Republic in the period 1919-23 was the extreme right" How far do you agree with this judgement? The Weimar Republic was created at a time of confusion and chaos after Germany had lost the First World War. Many people felt that Germany had received a very harsh deal in the Treaty of Versailles and they resented the government for signing it and agreeing to its conditions. In the period 1919-23 there were threats to

An Unnatural Alliance That Was Bound to Fall Apart After the Defeat of the Common Enemy. to What Extent Does This Statement Explain the Origin of the Cold War

1842 words - 8 pages emerged representing directly conflicting ideologies which created from the start an “unnatural alliance” that was “bound to fall apart” and more so after the “defeat of the common enemy” as by then they did not need each other anymore. Their alliance was bound to fall apart as they supported contrasting principles where each believed that the other threatened what they stood for. The events until the defeat of Germany where a power vacuum in

Does A Typical Or Ideal Family/Household Exist In Modern British Society?

1046 words - 5 pages this family both work and the child does his /her own work.One- parent is a family where the Children live with one of their parent usually mother who has separated from her husband and decides not marry again and live with her Children. As this family is often small and incomplete so the members of the family give more time to each other and try to fill the vacuum of the missing person.If the child does not have a brother or sister then he tries to make more friends to fill the emptiness in his/her life.

In the Early Nineteenth Century Americans Sought to Resolve Their Political Disputes Through Compromise Yet by 1860 This No Longer Seemed Possible

849 words - 4 pages the daughter of Rhea and Cronus. 24. Hermes is the son of Zeus and Maia. 25. Persephone is the daughter of Poseidon and Demeter. III. The Greeks believed in many Gods/Goddesses. Every Greek God/Goddess had a name and a role. All Greek God/Goddess has so many fun facts. Greek Gods/goddesses are all connected by family. Every Greek God/Goddess are important to Greek society.

Related Papers

Plato’s The Republic Essay

1580 words - 7 pages the philosophers’ unwillingness will be an advantage to the governing of the society, as the good of the society will be the only objective for which they are concerned within this job role as rulers. Plato’s idea on the acquisition of knowledge is very much dependent on his theory of forms. If this theory falls apart, then does the status of his philosophers as the governors of society. For the philosopher ruler is

The Role Of Women In The Roman Republic

3609 words - 15 pages THE ROLE OF WOMEN IN THE ROMAN REPUBLICTraditionally, women were viewed as weak-minded, or levitas animi, and because of this, they would be closely scrutinized by a male who would act as her guardian. Women were also strictly monitored by not only their husbands and fathers but also by the social restrictions and laws of the time. All is not lost for the women of the Roman Republic however, the contributions of Roman women to history amount to

‘A Gets B To Do Something That He Or She Would Not Otherwise Do.’ Does This Sum Up The Essence Of Political Power?

1944 words - 8 pages question arises. What if B agrees with A, thus agrees to do what he is asked to? Then we are not sure if what makes B take action is A's power or if their interests both coincide. Another explanation could be that B doesn't have complete information as to what is in his best interest. This could be the case if A withholds some information from him, or if B does not have the capacity to understand the political situation he is in. This is what Karl

Of Mice And Men – How Does Steinbeck Make This Extract A Particularly Powerful Moment In The Novel?

596 words - 3 pages Of mice and men – how does Steinbeck make this extract a particularly powerful moment in the novel? The begging of chapter 6 is the same as chapter 1. I think this symbolises the beginning and the end of the story, meaning the end of an era for George and Lennie. Just as at the begging Steinbeck describes Lennie as “dragging his feet, the way a bear drags his paws” and then again at chapter 6 he says Lennie has “creeping bear moves