This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Whistle Blowing Essay

1708 words - 7 pages

Whistle blowing is an attempt by an employee or former employer of an organization to disclose what she or he believes to be wrong doing sin or by the organization (James 1995)
In Whistleblowing, raising concerns and speaking up are all phrases which describe disclosing information to an employer or where appropriate a regulator, police or the media about malpractice, wrongdoing or a risk to safety.
Whistleblowing is providing a solution to resolve such situations: it opens nonexistent or hidden information sources and channels. The reasons for revealing information can be manifold: e.g. when someone notices such an abuse at his/her place of work and would like ...view middle of the document...

Responsible people blow the whistle when they believe more harm than good will occur if the whistleblower stays silent. A virtuous whistleblower acts in an ethical manner if she truly believes a responsibility exists to protect the public interest. Such a person is willing to accept the consequences of her actions. i.e., she is accountable for her actions.
Loyalty is a powerful ethical value and may inhibit a would-be-whistleblower from coming forward. However, an example would be of where loyalty trumped higher ethical values, such as honesty and integrity, with the result being that financial fraud was not disclosed as it would have devastating results to shareholders.

We need to ensure that all workers are able to raise concerns about such issues early and effectively, as it is in everyone’s interests that suspected malpractice or wrong doing is dealt with properly. Speaking up promptly can make the difference between a disaster averted and long term damage to business and the wider public.

Is whistle blowing ethical or moral?
The most important consideration in assessing whether a whistleblower acts in an ethical manner is the intention for one’s action. Is it to right a wrong? Is it to give voice to one’s values in the face of countervailing forces? Or, is the basis for the action the pursuit of self-interests, which may manifest itself in blowing the whistle in order to cash in on the whistle-blower award? After all, greed is a powerful motivating force when considering whether to blow the whistle on financial wrongdoing.
An ethical person is one who possesses strong character traits built on courage and informed by the belief that integrity is the backbone of ethical decision-making. A would-be-whistleblower is willing to stand her ground even in the face of pressure from higher-ups to stay silent. It’s not because of the possibility of receiving a whistleblower’s award. Instead, the whistleblower believes in principled behavior and leads her life in accordance with ethical values.
Different theories are used to argue the ethics on whistle blowing

1.The Kantian theory instructs people to act in harmony with universally accepted rules telling the truth is at the heart of the deontological theory (Kant 1996). Kant however did not consider the self sacrifice that is often required in whistle blowing though it would be implied that Kant would want an individual to stand firm in telling the truth, regardless of personal outcome.

2.The virtue theory requires an individual to personify integrity and courage. (Adams, 2006: Bolsin et al, 2005) We use the example of a doctor working in a hospital. Reporting unethical colleague, or health care fraud requires the integrity found in professional character. The primary goal of a doctor is to remain loyal to providing relief to a patient in suffering. Turning a blind eye to practices that go against the primary aim would not only breach the doctor’s code of ethics but it would also...

Other Essays Like Whistle Blowing

International Business Essay

2883 words - 12 pages Sample Case 1 Ethics and Social Responsibility Case A New Concern for Human Resource Managers: Whistle-Blowing Each year Time dedicates a front cover of its magazine to a “Person of the Year.” Last year, for example, New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuilani was given such an honor for his handling of New York’s 9/11 terrorist crisis. This year Time expanded its version of the person of the year. It dedicated its cover to “Persons of the Year.” The

Training and Enforcement Essay

1617 words - 7 pages . Every company comes across morals issues. Whistle blowing and open door policies is two that this company stands by. FedUP has one golden rule, “Give respect to receive respect.” The call centers have came up with a new way of learning the in’s and out’s of the company. Learning the specific job code and center can help the new employee have all the experience to be ethically trained. Coming into new surrounding can be a little scary at first, but


2633 words - 11 pages I couldn’t live with myself if I hadn’t done anything…because it was speak up or stroke out……what else could I do, and I have to look at myself in the mirror every morning (Alford, 2007). Choiceless choice makes whistle-blowing an agony, a struggle between sender and receiver. Stuck in Static Time Second, there is stuck in static time. It is the turbulence of stagnant motion often realized when whistleblowers have been ostracized. In

Creative Paper on a Childhood Memory

442 words - 2 pages mooing of the cows. Roosters crowing in time with the ringing of the bell as boys tried to impress their girlfriends with a show of strength. Pigs and piglets squealing as the little train went by, it's mini locomotive blowing it's piercing whistle. All of it making a strange mix of sites, sounds and smells that I haven't had in a long, long time.But the thing that I remember most spending time by the cow stalls. For some reason I was mesmerized by

Business Ch 1 & 2 Dq

1379 words - 6 pages 64 2. How can an employee take an ethical stand regarding a business decision when his or her superior has taken a different position? As the book explains that there is an option called whistle-blowing which is to draw attention to the unethical practice of that supervisor, but I believe that is the action to be taken as a las resort option. As the book explained, with most businesses, there is a code of ethics that is either develop or


1659 words - 7 pages eighth scenario, the employer is taking an action against the employee on a particular act, but the reference to the employment at will doctrine and the whistle blowing policy will matter. The reason is that the employee can take help with the contents mentioned in the employment at will doctrine. Though, the company did not have any whistle blowing policy which means that the employee did not have any protection under this concept. Therefore

Int Business

4976 words - 20 pages giving b. ethical compliance c. legal compliance d. all of the above e. none of the above (d; moderate; p. 133) 63. The term _____ refers to the disclosure by an employee of illegal or unethical conduct on the part of others within the organization. a. honesty b. whistle-blowing c. acknowledgement d. conflict of interest e. organizational communication

Working with Children and Young People Level 3

659 words - 3 pages . The second part - The steps employers and senior colleagues in the setting or service need to take to protect themselves and other colleagues.. This is all about safeguarding children - think about staff training (does you setting have different child protection training for different staff members, we have a basic one for staff but one for managers about allegations on staff etc), correct staffing ratios, whistle blowing policy, CRBS, the effective recruitment of staff

Section 5 Nvq 3

655 words - 3 pages around to pass such information to the supervisors or the appropriate bodies to take appropriate actions. In most cases organisations have whistleblowing policies to guide and protect staff from victimisation after blowing the whistle, and also to guide them on how to break confidentiality. You should seek advice on confidentiality whenever you are asked to disclose information, (in writing or verbally) about an individual. That includes

Human Resource Management

1203 words - 5 pages resulting from the employee’s gender or if it is sexually offensive, humiliating or intimidating. Conduct of this nature by an employee or third party towards an employee will constitute sexual harassment. What are your policies regarding whistle blowing? MBL whistle blowing policy states that if an employee observes any suspicious, fraudulent or unethical activity, transaction or act that may cause a potential threat to the bank or

American Civil Law System

1204 words - 5 pages build record, while others to bring case to sound decision. In most important litigation, both criminal and civil, judges normally sit in panels (Koch, 2004). Therefore, this law system, with numerous judges involved, creates many opportunities of whistle blowing. Threat of whistle blowing ensures level of reliability and integrity. Collegiality creates encouragements for acting inside institutional norms as well as a deterrent against juries

Related Papers

Whistle Blowing Essay

891 words - 4 pages ------------------------------------------------- Assignment 1: Whistleblowing and Sarbanes-Oxley LEG 500 LEG 500 Whistle blowing has its origins from an example of law enforcement blowing a whistle when someone finds a crime or some wrongdoing process in a government. So when wrongs are taking place in government, the public they serve suffers (Chambers, 2014). The government is supposed to be open. Whistleblowers have to care

Engineering Ethics Essay

3146 words - 13 pages THE ETHICAL ANALYSIS ON THE ISSUES OF WHISTLE BLOWING Final Report for ELEC4122 Strategic Leadership & Ethics The university of New South Wales Australia, Sydney ABSTRACT: The report presents the framework analysis on the engineering ethical issues on the whistle blowing. The whistle blowing is essential to this society to keep the justice and public safety. It is the way to fight with the corruption and public hazards. From

Behavior Of An Organization Essay

1040 words - 5 pages Whistle Blowers: Saints or Sinners Introduction: Whistle blowers are individuals who prevent the wrongdoing or illegal activities from an organization. Douglas Duran a former of sales at TAP Pharmaceutical Products files the petition to high Court to reveal the wrongdoing of his company. He is considered to be a Whistle Blower. In this case, he is a saint or a sinner? 1/ - David Stetler a defense attorney believe that Whistle Blowing means

The Un Ethical Stealing Of An Employee Sales

938 words - 4 pages Whistle Blowing On A Manager Ethical Or Not Is Whistle Blowing On A Manager Ethical Or Not? Business Ethics Name Here Excelsior Online College This paper is prepared for Business Ethics 323 taught by Professor Andrea Lucas. Abstract Dealing with whistle blowing on the store manager, I found to have great internal ethical conflict. Even with none