Why Did The 1905 Russian Revolution Fail

550 words - 3 pages

‘What 1905 showed was that as long as the Tsarist government kept its nerve and the army remained loyal, the forces of protest would find it very difficult to mount a serious challenge.’ –p.39 Reaction and Revolution.

The failure of the revolution in 1905 was caused by many different contributing factors, however the key reason for the failure, was the success of state authority in retaining control. If the Tsarist state had collapsed, as in 1917, the revolution would have inevitably been successful.

A revolution means to forcibly overthrow a government or social order, for a new system. However, this simply cannot be possible if the state authority (controlled by the government) does not collapse. The survival of state authority was fundamentally the reason for the failure of the 1905 revolution. Trotsky once said ...view middle of the document...

The Black Hundreds, a counter revolutionary pro-government terrorist group also helped the military to hunt down and ‘execute’ thousands of known reformers.

Apart from the Tsarist system remaining strong, there was also a problem with the revolution itself. The revolt lacked any central coordination. The spontaneity of the revolutionary outbreaks meant that the armed forces, the police and the Black Hundreds could suppress them one by one.

Not only was there the problem of control. The revolt lacked was direction. The revolutionaries had many different aims. For example, the liberals wanted to share power with the Tsar. The social revolutionaries wanted peasant ownership of land. The social democrats, who were divided between the Bolsheviks and the Mensheviks, wanted to completely change society and remove the Tsar. This meant that often, different radical parties would fight amongst themselves as much as they did whilst opposing the government.

As well as the unorganised nature of the revolt, another reason for its failure was the ease with which the government managed to appease the revolutionaries. For example, the Tsar promised to set up a constitutional government, a range of civil rights, including freedom of speech, assembly and worship and the legalising of trade unions, which many liberals in particular saw as enough of a success to abort the revolution.

This meant that through a combination of concession and repression the Tsarist’s government could easily control the revolution.

The Russian defeat in the Russio-Japanese war was also a reason for its failure, although it too was a cause of the revolution. It was a failure on one hand because of how quickly it was over. Had it continued, it had the potential to fuel an even bigger, more organised revolt.

So through a policy of concession and repression, state authority and divided opposition the 1905 revolution failed.

Other Essays Like Why Did the 1905 Russian Revolution Fail

How Was the Tsar Able to Survive the 1905 Revolution

805 words - 4 pages How was the Tsar able to survive the 1905 revolution? Despite the failure of Russia in the war against Japan, the Tsarist regime survived the revolution remarkable unscathed. There are a number of reasons for this. Although a large proportion of the Russian population expressed their opposition to the Tsarist regime during events of 1905 it was not organised protest. Each group had its own grievances and separate set of demands. The

The Russian Revolution And Animal Farm

1449 words - 6 pages The book Animal Farm by George Orwell was written in comparison to the way that the Russian revolution had taken place. The main idea of the book was that the petite bourgeoisie’s (the middle class people) were the ones who took advantage of the revolt. The petite bourgeoisie moved up the social tower to be the bourgeoisie (the noble class). The proletariat (peasants) did not want to rebel because they were to worried about what they were

How Far Was the Russo-Japanese War Responsible for the Outbreak of the 1905 Revolution?

1794 words - 8 pages they had possessed before the start of the war. Another example of a great failure of the military was at the Battle of Tsushima in May 1905. The Russian Baltic fleet consisting of the 35 warships had sailed from northern Europe to the Far East, only to lose 25 warships in a defeat by the Japanese navy. The crushing of Russian’s military added impetus to the 1905 Revolution, as it made the people of Russia aware of the weakness of their military

Why Did the Welfare State Happen?

2095 words - 9 pages Why did the Welfare State happen in the 1940s? This essay will discuss the beginning of the welfare state, the liberal reforms, the importance of the labour party, and Beveridges role within the welfare state and how it came to be. The welfare state was established by 1945-51. The Labour government is generally recognized as representing a crucial development in welfare provision. An enquiry was established in 1941 to propose how best to

One Woman's Insightful Views on the Causes of Marital Failure: "Why Marriages Fail" by Anne Roiphe

502 words - 3 pages Anne Roiphe's essay, "Why Marriages Fail" digs into the causes of marital break up (Roiphe, 2005, p. 524-526). Some of the reasons that she lists for divorce include unrealistic expectations, choosing partners that possess negative traits of our mother or father, lack of communication and unhealthy dependency on our significant other. Although Roiphe is not formally educated in marital psychology, many of her works have focused on similar issues

Why Did the King Make the Flight to Varennes

602 words - 3 pages Why Did The King Make The Flight To Varennes? The flight of King Louis is best explained by an accumulation of long term and short term causes, based on the beliefs and intentions of people at the time, and the existing conditions in France at that time. The French people were against the King as they believed in the ideals of the new constitution; fraternity, liberty and equality. And the new constitution greatly decreased teh kings power

Why Did the Romans Win the Second Punic War?

686 words - 3 pages Overall there are three major factors as to why the romans won the second punic war they include Hannibal's unwillingness to adapt his war aim being to destroy the roman confederacy rather than destroy rome, Hannibal's lack of support from Carthage which greatly disadvantage him and the final main reason being Rome persistence and hard work including their inexhaustible man power and support from citizens and allies. Hannibal conducted

Why Did The Vikings Go Fighting And Raiding?

1322 words - 6 pages Why Did The Vikings Go Fighting And Raiding? What Food Did The Vikings Eat? What Clothes Did The Vikings Wear? Conclusion Bibliography Why Did The Vikings Go Fighting And Raiding? The Vikings started to raid towns because back at home, they didn’t have enough food to feed them all. When they got what they wanted they fought for something else, gold, silver, money etc. England was a very good country to raid because it is

Why Did The US Enter World War II Late?

2930 words - 12 pages .America's hesitancy was shaped by various factors, namely "the desire to avoid entanglement in European affairs...the conviction that intervention in World War I was wrong [and] the focus on domestic issues during the Great Depression. " The following shall analyze and explain why the United States did not enter World War II until December 8th of 1941 and advocates of American intervention were not able to do so previous to Pearl Harbor. To obtain a

Why Did the Americans Withdraw from South Vietnam in 1973?

2129 words - 9 pages ’ as the US troops would not get the peasants of Vietnam on their side and instead would follow the Vietcong’s side. This played a major part in the withdrawal in Vietnam as during the Vietnam War, a lot of innocent civilians were killed and due to the effect of the media and no censorship, Americans did not like what they were seeing or hearing. There were still other failures of US tactics as well as the unpopularity of them which itself lead

Why Did The Bolsheviks Find It Necessary To Execute The Romanovs?

271 words - 2 pages Why did the Bolsheviks find it necessary to execute the Romanovs? To the Romanovs, no compromise was good enough, the Romanov dynasty wanted to continue the war and delay all reforms until the war was over. The Bolsheviks wanted absolute power over Russia. The Romanovs relentless tactics in fighting the war undid the temporary government. The Bolsheviks, led by Lenin, whose slogan was "All power to the soviets!", undermined the

Related Papers

Why Did The 1905 Revolution Take Place?

927 words - 4 pages was a major problem for him because his laws and beliefs were orthodox Christian views which some people did not abide by as they were not all Christians and this is why Nicholass attempt on russification failed.In conlusion I think the main problem the Tsar faced was the economic problems as his inability to set up trade between countries, a growth in industry and agriculture lead to many to no improvements in the country. Secondly him not

Why Did The Spanish Armada Fail?

818 words - 4 pages There are many reasons why the Spanish Armada failed but one of the most important reasons is simply because they were not organized and prepared. They came into battle being arrogant. The Spanish were not prepared for the worst thing that could happen. The English planned what they were going to do step by step. They surprised the Spanish by waiting for them at sea instead of having a land battle with them. All of this history is very

Why Was There A Revolution In Russia In 1905?

374 words - 2 pages The Russian Revolution of 1905 was both anti-government and undirected violence against its Tsar. It was not controlled or managed. The causes were simple, freedom/democracy, food/jobs, which were led by the Socialist Revolutionary party and the workers, influenced by Marxism, were represented in the Bolshevik and Menshevik wings of the Social Democratic Labor party.The revolution was the culmination of a long period of repression and unrest

Causes Of The Russian Revolution Essay

665 words - 3 pages Russian Revolution were World War One, poverty, and the Russo-Japanese War. Communism had major effects in the world, because it caused many of the major wars in modern history. Communism affected the whole world, not only the countries which became communist. This is why we should be able to determine the major causes of such a significant event in history. One of the most important causes of the Russian Revolution was the First World