Why Immigration Reform Is Unnecessary Essay

1180 words - 5 pages

In 2010, approximately 11.2 million undocumented immigrants resided in the United States (Passel & Cohn, 2011). Citizens of other countries migrate to America for different reasons to receive better education opportunities, to earn enough income to support family members still living in their homelands, and to ultimately experience the American way of life. Some politicians, lawmakers, and American citizens believe that entry into the country should be regulated and, to a certain extent, restricted for economic, security and cultural reasons. I argue that Immigration Reform is not needed in the United States because it will have detrimental effects on the economic stability, innovation, and ...view middle of the document...

For example, illegal immigrants consume goods and services while being in America, and subsequently have to pay things such as sales tax. According to Julian Simon, a former professor, practically none receive social security but 77 percent pay social security taxes, and 73 percent have federal taxes withheld (Simon, p. 265). Immigrants tend to fill job positions that most Americans would not want to work because of pride and pay. For instance, immigrants from Mexico often take on service positions such as cleaning and yard maintenance for reduced pay. Since these individuals are willing to work for lower pay, operation costs for businesses are reduced, thereby allowing for more competitive prices. Lower prices result in more purchasing power for Americans, and subsequently fuel the economy (Lehman, 2012).
Another reason why immigration reform is not needed is because restriction of immigrants coming into the country will obstruct the open exchange of new ideas and innovation. Recently, emphasis has been placed on the importance of science and ingenuity in keeping America modern and competitive in the new world. Some immigrants are influential in the advancement of the country because they bring both intellect and brain power to the U.S. The Brookings Institution Report reported there areas are more high-skilled immigrants migrating to the Unites States than low-skilled ones. They also reported that in 2010 thirty percent of working-age immigrants had at least a college degree and twenty-eight percent lacked a high school diploma (Florida, 2011). These individuals are able to use their education, skills, expertise and ideas toward the betterment of the country.
Finally, restricting free entrance into the U.S. and implementing a challenging path to citizenship could potentially effect the country’s reputation. When compared to other countries, the U.S. has earned the reputation of being the land of opportunity. America was founded by immigrants that provided achieving religious freedom, gaining economic independence and new opportunities. Immigration Reform would slowly tarnish this reputation. Without such a reform the population develops a greater sense of tolerance for diverse cultural practices, languages, races and religions.
The above mentioned reasons for finding Immigration Reform necessary are flawed. The claim that without the reform criminals and terrorist will have a breeding ground to engage in illegal activity is inaccurate and oversimplified. As with any country, there are citizens who engage in illegal activity. For example, American citizen Jose Padilla constructed plans with al Qaeda to detonate a bomb on American soil, and was subsequently caught in 2002 (Fantz, 2011). Proper security measures can be taken to ensure that national security is not compromised without...

Other Essays Like Why Immigration Reform Is Unnecessary

Immigration Inform Essay

2199 words - 9 pages those who are employed are tired of the below market wages, and the unequal treatment. Today they are about 11 million undocumented workers in the United States and Americans fear that because of this matter, immigrants will increase cost, overwhelm the country, and change American society. Immigration Reform Immigration statistics will prove how rapidly immigration is increasing

Immigration Reform Essay

2530 words - 11 pages Immigration Reform Elizabeth Garza English112 October 15, 2011 Immigration Reform The question of whether or not to allow illegal immigrants to remain in this country and eventually become citizens of the United States is a hotly debated issue. Illegal immigrants should have the right to amnesty. It does not make sense to spend billions of dollars rounding people up, breaking up families

Peer Review

1302 words - 6 pages Peer Review Team A has chosen to write their term paper on the economic effects of the current immigration policy. Team A in their thesis statements propose that “Our belief is that the current immigration system is plagued with inefficiencies that harm the U.S. economy. We intend to identify these inefficiencies and propose solutions to them. In terms of the given objectives of term assignment this is a strong start to a paper, and provides

The Competition Between Immigrants and Natives for Low-Wage Jobs

1057 words - 5 pages immigrants don't pay income taxes but do use schools and other government services. Getting benefit from the U.S. public services without paying taxes, this kind of behavior is showing that illegal immigration is an economic burden to the U.S. The Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) wrote in its Feb. 2011, “Illegal immigration costs U.S. taxpayers about $113 billion a year at the federal, state and local level… The annual outlay that

Immigration Policy Options In Tennessee

974 words - 4 pages confront is the elevated level of partisanship currently present in Congress and the federal government as a whole. Research demonstrates that over the last several decades, increasing division along party lines-- particularly in Congress’ voting patterns—has ignited simultaneous division over immigration policy and reform. A 2011 study released by the Immigration Reform Caucus of the House of Representatives revealed that agreement on


647 words - 3 pages Jordan Fleming 3-13-12 I believe immigration does contribute to a better America. The United States is known for its freedom and the opportunities that it presents for people to come over here to accomplish. which furthermore makes the case on the reason why a lot of immigrants come here from different countries. Usually the type of immigrants that do come to America are the ones with dreams, goals in that they want to

Is the New Immigration Really so Bad?

574 words - 3 pages David Card’s paper entitled Is the New Immigration Really So Bad? takes a look at U.S. immigration and focuses on two main questions: “1. Does immigration reduce the labor market opportunities of less-skilled natives? 2. Have immigrants who arrived after the 1965 Immigration Reform Act successfully assimilated?” One of the key ways Card measures the effectiveness of immigrants assimilation is based on the success’s of U.S. born children of

Congressman Chet Edwards

884 words - 4 pages protecting our borders and reducing illegal immigration. I would say it somewhat provides the framework for the Comprehensive Immigration Reform bill that President Obama hopes will be drafted by the end of this year (5). If we can create a system where the border security is strong, and where there is an orderly process for people to come in, that would be ideal. I think it would be a good thing that we would be giving those who are here in the

Blaw Assignment

1712 words - 7 pages the anticipated benefits of immigration reform? a. It could have a great economic benefit as the immigrants would start to pay taxes, but would not receive social security or Medicaid benefits for years. 13. What is the position of legislators who oppose President Obama’s executive order of deferred deportation and the argument that the executive order is illegal (not within the president’s powers)? a. Those opposed argue that President


1361 words - 6 pages executive orders on November 20, 2014 to help with immigration reform. Many people were angry that he took it upon himself to do this saying that it is illegal and immoral. Congress was working quickly to come up with a bill to block the President from this executive order, but could not pass it into law because of the Senate majority being Democrat. According to the New York Times this would apply to at least five million people. (Parlapiano

Cheryls Test

1078 words - 5 pages the U.S. Since then, numerous changes have been made to the U.S. policy of immigration. In a report on immigration policy changes, “the crackdown on immigration came long before 9/11/. The impact of post 9/11 legislation on immigration has been limited.” The biggest impact of 9/11 on immigration policy is that significant reform has been dropped from the political agenda. The best example is President Bush’s proposal for a guest worker program

Related Papers

Liberal Arts Capstone Essay

2188 words - 9 pages that border security is of the upmost importance in any immigration reform and that the senate bill adequately addresses it and that is why he urges the House to pass the senate’s bill and he will swiftly sign it into law. Many presidents in the past 2 decades have tried to pass immigration reform in congress and they have all come up short, but President Obama seem to have made immigration reform a huge deal amongst the population, a weary and

Current Event Article Essay

800 words - 4 pages to believe he will at least entertain the possibility of turning the hard-liners out a bit more this time around.” www.washingtonpost.com. . REASONS IMMIGRATION REFORM IS STILL UNFINISHED BUSINESS There are so many reasons why immigration reform is still at the negotiating table. However, there is not enough paper in the world to write them all down. Here are five just to name a few: 1

Administrative Regulations Assignments

1294 words - 6 pages 1. State the administrative agency which controls the regulation. Explain why this agency and your proposed regulation interests you (briefly). Will this proposed regulation affect you or the business in which you are working? If so, how? The subject of immigration is well known among students, workers, and employers, and in fact, to most everyone residing within the United States. For me, this topic is especially significant as I myself was

Immigration Essay

1790 words - 8 pages officer, it also stops illegal immigrants from avoiding inspection by immigration officers. Visa overstay is when someone with a Visa overstays their allotted time in the country. A Border Crossing Card is a card that authorizes border crossings into the US for a set amount of time. Which is why immigration reform became apart of immigration policies. Immigration reform is being used to change the current immigration policies. The first of these