Winning The Struggle Against China Essay

1403 words - 6 pages


In a military war, the Philippines does not stand a chance against China. In a word war, the odds are reversed. To win the struggle over disputed territories against China, it is pivotal therefore, that the Philippine government and Filipinos hammer on the merits of its claims.

On April 2012, the Philippines bowed down to China’s military supremacy. On April 10, Filipino sailors were prevented by Chinese ships from arresting Chinese fishermen discovered poaching corals and endangered species in Panatag (Scarborough) Shoal, located 124 nautical miles (M) off Zambales and over 550 M from China’s nearest port. A stand-off occurred but eventually the ...view middle of the document...

On January 22, 2013, after seventeen years of fruitless negotiations, the Philippines initiated an arbitration process under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Seas (UNCLOS) to declare (1) the nine-dash line illegal, interfering the Philippines’ rights over its EEZ and continental shelf, and (2) the small, uninhabitable coral projections barely above water at high tide, which China claims as “islands” as simply “rocks”.

Unenforceability of an ITLOS Judgment

Some are doubtful as to the benefit of the arbitral proceeding before the International Tribunal on the Law of the Seas (ITLOS). The whole process is deemed a futile exercise considering China’s refusal to participate in the proceeding. If the ruling is in favor of the Philippines, e.g. the nine-dash line is declared invalid and the status of the disputed reefs and shoals within the Philippines’ EEZ, China will simply refuse to honor the decision. On the other hand, if the pronouncement is in favor of China, e.g. the body rejects the Philippines’ claims and declares the nine-dash line valid, the Philippines would lose face and worse yet, territories that are rightfully its own.

Other Alternatives

Some sectors posit that boosting the country’s military capabilities is key to the WPS dispute. Modernization of equipment and/or grant of access to bases to the US, Japan, and other allies are seen as crucial to defending the Philippines against China’s expansionism.

Others propose peaceful resolution of the conflict through joint explorations in the disputed areas. They assert that since the issue boils down to natural resources and shipping lanes, cooperation, rather than antagonism, is the solution.

What Is The Most Feasible Policy Option?

At this point, the Philippines is not prepared for a confrontation with China. The arrival of its second Hamilton-class weather high endurance cutter, which can operate on higher sea states compared to all Philippine Navy warships, does not negate the recent statement that Philippine military equipment is like a “balisong” (fan knife) compared to China’s “machine gun.” History dictates China’s regional military supremacy. Other than the Panatag incident, it is worth recalling that in 1974, China defeated the Vietnamese forces and successfully occupied the Paracel Islands. Similarly, in 1994, while the Philippine navy was patrolling elsewhere, Chinese troops occupied Mischief Reef (130 M off Palawan) and turned it into a naval station.

Admittedly, assistance from the US, Japan, and other allies, in the form of financial aid, equipment, and training, will boost the country’s military capabilities. But, it should be underscored that the 1987 Constitution places boundaries on foreign assistance and limits the presence of foreign troops in the Philippines. More importantly, even if the country relies too heavily on its allies, there is no guarantee that they would join the Philippines in a war against China. In any case,...

Other Essays Like Winning the Struggle Against China

Rise and Risk of China Essay

1702 words - 7 pages ” (Shen 2009, 4) in the Asia-Pacific region. Since the establishment of the PRC in 1949, the Chinese Communist Party has maintained that reunification with Taiwan is a matter of “sovereignty, security, territorial integrity, regime survival and [ruling] legitimacy” (Shen 2009, 52). With the US “containment policy against communism [and] dominant leadership in the region and the international order”, China regards the US as “the key hindrance to the

Mao's CUltural Revolution Essay

2846 words - 12 pages of Mao and his followers to avoid humiliation or death. These rebelling youths tore through streets, houses, and cultural heritages destroying all deemed 'suspicious'. This greatly affected China's population as the people lived in fear while China was losing control of its youth and spiraling into social turmoil. Mao's Cultural Revolution called for all the youth of China to band together and rebel against the 'capitalist roaders', which

The Great Wall of China

3041 words - 13 pages to do with political and economic systems? 6 The cultural revolution created chaos in China. Schools closed. In factories, disputes between rival factions slowed production. Finally, in 1969, the Chinese army restored order, sending millions of young Red Guards to work in faraway rural areas. The emphasis on political struggle continued until Mao’s death. Many people had been tortured, imprisoned and killed. All in all a smashing time to be

Eu and China Relations

3580 words - 15 pages Europe’s potential role as a new pole in a future multipolar world order and not only as a stronghold against Soviet hegemonies as in the 1970’s (Volgy pg, 90). There was a growing realization in Beijing at the time that the European integration process would have a major role to play the gradual political emancipation of Eastern Europe from Moscow. In the post-Cold War era, both the EU and China intend to play a greater role in international affairs

Case Study Analysis

1086 words - 5 pages   awareness   of   counterfeits  and  stemmed  the  flow  of  the  counterfeits  from  China  to  the  developed   world.  It  also  brought  legal  actions  against  pirates  who  made  fake  goods,  as  well  as   landlords   who   provided   operation   locations   for   the   pirates.   LVMH   has   achieved   much

The Forgotten Legacy of China as a Great Ally

1285 words - 6 pages Grace Holden Professor Wei Quiz 4 4.18. 16 Commonly misconstrued, conflict aroused by Japan did not start with the bombing of Pearl Harbor, but started many years prior in China. China had been at war with Japan since 1937 (though faced encroachments from Japan beginning in 1931), with the Marco Polo Bridge incident. The long fight that China put up against Japan up until 1941 is often discredited or even disregarded because the attack on

What the Government Should Do in Regard to China Policy Following the 2013 Federal Election

3094 words - 13 pages What the Government should do in regard to China policy following the 2013 Federal Election 30 July 2013 at 22:44 Some Australian commentators claim that Australia is at a cross roads, and that it is unprecedented that its largest trading partner is not its closest ally.[1] In fact, its major ally and largest trading partner are engaged in a Cold War power struggle. They go on to say that solving this ‘unprecedented’ situation is Australia’s

Chinese Presence in Africa

4364 words - 18 pages of President Thabo Mbeki’s government, China’s influence on South Africa coupled with its BRIC countries alliance with (Russia, India, Brazil and South Africa) had a huge impact on South Africa to further strengthen their relationship collaboration with China. This close relationship with China was tested when “China-India and Brazil” which once cooperated with the US turned against the US and the EU in the “Doha trade round”, moreover, South

3 Etfs Set to Soar During the Recovery

1961 words - 8 pages all of the emerging economies are as closely coupled to developed economies as we previously thought. Emerging economies that are largely dependent on America -- like Mexico, for example -- will continue to struggle as America emerges from the meltdown. And Eastern European economies, many of which are mired in debt, could take years to turn around. But the situation in China isn't nearly as dire as analysts predicted just a few months ago. In

Beginng of the Great Revival

3965 words - 16 pages rallied opposition against Hunan's warlord Zhang Jingyao. The May Fourth Movement covered more than 20 provinces and over 100 cities of the country. It had a broader popular foundation than the Revolution of 1911. Its great contribution lay in arousing the people's consciousness and preparing for the unity of the revolutionary forces. The May Fourth Movement promoted the spreading of Marxism in China, and prepared the ideological foundation for

Foreign Relations of China

2426 words - 10 pages Treaty of Friendship, Alliance, and Mutual Assistance signed in 1950 to oppose China's chief antagonists, the West and in particular the United States. The 1950–53 Korean War waged by China and its North Korea ally against the United States, South Korea, and United Nations (UN) forces has long been a reason for bitter feelings. After the conclusion of the Korean conflict, China sought to balance its identification as a member of the Soviet bloc by

Related Papers

Business Culture And Strategy Essay

2417 words - 10 pages this report. Section 1 How China Telecom develop plans for customer care strategy The customer care strategy of China Telecom is “Customer First, Service Foremost”. China Telecom considers customers to be food and clothing suppliers, they bearing this concept in mind. Keeping service foremost considered as the ultimate goal of China Telecom and is the sole choice for winning satisfaction from customer. China Telecom implementing this

Japan And Its Entrance Into The West

1324 words - 6 pages against China over its interest in Korea, which China claimed as a provincial state. The Japanese were worried that the Russians might gain control of the Korean peninsula. Japan won the war against China and gained control over Korea and gained Taiwan as a colony. Meiji Japan had regained complete control of its foreign trade and legal system, and, by fighting and winning two wars (the second against Russia); it had established full independence

An Examination Of The Communist Revolution Of China As A Representation Of Marxism And Maoism

4245 words - 17 pages machines. One worker could replace another, they are both equal and the same. Unindustrialized, China did not have this problem. Since the horrors of industry were known by relatively few, it made little impact in much of China. It is horrors like absence of job security, lack of protection against dangerous machines, long work hours (usually over seventy hours a week), and bare subsistence income (just to name a few) which forces the workers to

Explain Why Civil War Broke Out In China In 1946

920 words - 4 pages each other and soon resorted to an intensive struggle for control of Manchuria as they lacked a common enemy to fight against. When the Americans entered the war and began fighting against Japan, the nationalists had hoped that they would drive Japan out of China and force it to surrender, bringing the Guomindang glory and support from the people. Whilst the americans did ensure Japan's surrender, it was not the way the nationalist had imagined